Thu 19 Jan 2012
KID REVIEW: Jaiden enjoys “Betsy Red Hoodie”
Posted by Pat under Book reviews
[5] Comments
If you think Betsy Red Hoodie (Harper, 2010) written by Gail Carson Levine and illustrated by Scott Nash is just another telling of the story Little Red Riding Hood, you’re mistaken.
True, the picture book nods at the classic children’s tale, but then it merrily skips off in another direction entirely.
Let’s start with the similarities. Betsy Red Hoodie sets off to deliver cupcakes to her grandmother. Through the forest. By herself. Wearing, well … you know what.
But this Betsy is a shepherd, so she takes her sheep with her. And the village’s other shepherd comes along too. A wolf named Zimmo.
Betsy is warned by others that Zimmo might not be trustworthy around grandmothers because, “Long ago, a wolf had eaten a grandma.” But Betsy believes in her friend.
However, the journey through the forest is far from easy. And halfway through it, Zimmo abandons Betsy and the flock. Did he race off ahead to eat her grandmother?
Like a good shepherd, Betsy stays with her flock and helps them find a lost sheep, survive a sudden rainstorm and a slog up a very muddy hill. (My favorite line? “Wool should be dry cleaned.”)
When a tired, worried Betsy finally arrives, her grandmother’s cottage is very dark. She fears the worst. But instead, she finds something very affirming and unexpected inside.
To hear more, let’s turn things over to today’s guest reviewer.
Today’s reviewer: Jaiden.
Age: 7
Things I like to do: Play “olden days” and chase.
This book was about: Betsy going to deliver cupcakes to her grandma.
The best part was when: Betsy found out what the wolf was doing.
I was worried when: The wolf ran ahead and didn’t tell Betsy what he was doing.
This book taught me: To trust your friends.
Three words that best describe this book: “Cool.” “Interesting.” “Fun.”
My favorite line or phrase in the book is: “Surprise!”
Other kids reading this book should watch for: The funny hats the sheep wear.
You should read this book because: It’s not anything like the real story of “Little Red Riding Hood.”
Thanks, Jaiden!
Gail Carson Levine is the author of the Newbery Honor Book Ella Enchanted along with Ever, Fairest, Dave at Night, The Wish, The Two Princesses of Bamarre and Betsy Who Cried Wolf. You can learn more about her by visiting her website.
Scott Nash has illustrated many books for children, including Betsy Who Cried Wolf. You can visit him online at this website.

Great review Jaiden – you did a terrific job. I love your red cape too.
Great review.
What a fun twist on the classic tale! I love the “wool should be dry cleaned” line, too. Thanks for the review (and the special guest review)!
Great review! I wonder if this is appropriate for kids who don’t know the “traditional” Red Riding Hood story?
Love the review. I admit to enjoying a good fairy tale retelling so I’m looking forward to reading this one.