Sonia and Two of a KindThere are all kinds of picture books.

Some are educational. Some are goofy. Some rhyme. Some have no words at all. And some prompt my daughter to say, “Well, that was odd,” after she turns the last page.

Then, there are some picture books that reflect the realities of childhood so clearly and accurately that all you can do after you’ve read them is nod, and maybe remember.

Jacqui Robbins’ picture book Two of Kind (Atheneum Books for Young Readers, 2009) describes a situation familar to children, teachers and parents — the ins and outs of being in, or out.

Kayla and Melanie are best friends. “Two of a kind,” everyone calls them. But they don’t allow others into their group, and they tease Anna and Julisa because they answer questions in class, help the teacher and wear glasses.

When Anna attracts Kayla and Melanie’s attention because she can do a cool science experiment, Anna has a choice. Will she become friends with more popular girls who are mean to her and others? Or will she stay friends with Julisa, who’s definitely not part of the in crowd but likes the same books and is always nice to her?

The book doesn’t offer a simple solution. Anna struggles before choosing friendship over popularity. And it’s a struggle any kid who’s ever been in day care or school can relate to.

Just ask Sonia.

Our reviewer: Sonia

Age: 8

I like: Playing with my DS game. Snuggling with my cat, Vince. Snuggling with my mommy and daddy.

The book was about: Four girls — Anna, Julisa, Melanie and Kayla. Melanie and Kayla don’t get along with Julisa and Anna. But then, they want to play with Anna but not Julisa. This makes Julisa feel sad.

The best part was when: Anna and Julisa said anyone was invited to play with them under the slide. But no one comes except Henry and Matthew.

I laughed when: This was a sad and happy book. I was sad when Anna and Julisa weren’t friends. But I laughed when Anna says, “I am already down” and runs off with Julisa holding her hand.

I was worried when: When Anna wasn’t paying attention to Julisa at reading time and at lunch.

I was surprised that: Their glasses fell off when they laughed.

This book taught me: To play with everybody.

Other kids reading this book should watch for: Julisa and Anna being happy instead of sad.

Three words that describe this book are: “Two.” “Friends.” “Kind.”

My favorite line or phrase in the book is: “Kayla and Melanie take my cookies. They say, ‘Mmm, yum!’ and dance like the girl on TV.”

You should read this book because: It shows good friendships.

Thanks, Sonia!

Jacqui has an informative Web site and a wonderful blog where she talks about writing, children’s books and her family. Plus, she’s funny. Really, truly funny.

Illustrator Matt Phelan also has an awesome Web site. Be warned. Matt has illustrated a lot of books. You could get lost just admiring them all. As you look at his body of work, you’ll want to pay particular attention to:

  • The two Jacqui Robbins’ picture books Matt has illustrated — Two of a Kind and The New Girl.
  • The Higher Power of Lucky, the Newbery winner he illustrated for author Susan Patron. 
  • Matt’s recent graphic novel — The Storm in the Barn (Candlewick, 2009).