Sat 26 Sep 2009
KID REVIEW: Join Jaiden in discussing A Tree for Emmy
Posted by Pat under Book reviews
[4] Comments

Today’s reviewer: Jaiden, 5. (Jaiden also answers to “Princess Reads-a-Lot.”)
Jaiden likes: Playing with friends and eating mac-and-cheese and cake.
The book: A Tree for Emmy (Peachtree, 2009). Written by Mary Ann Rodman. Illustrated by Tatjana Mai-Wyss.
What happens: Emmy wanted a tree and she found a small tree and she didn’t want it, but then she did.
The best part was when: She found a baby mimosa.
I laughed when: Her Gramma called her stubborn and strong and a little bit wild.
I was worried when: She cried on her bed.
I was sad when: She couldn’t find a mimosa.
I was surprised that: She got a mimosa tree.
This book taught me: You should be stubborn and wild and a little bit crazy.
This book also taught me: Even if it isn’t what you want, it is going to be what you want if you have patience.
Other kids reading this book should: Look at the sweater she’s wearing in the fall.
Three words that best describe this book are: Stubborn, strong and wild.
My favorite line or phrase in the book is: When Emmy sings, “My tree, my tree, my beautiful tree!”
You should read this because: It’s funny.
Thanks for joining Read, Write, Repeat, Jaiden!
Want to know more? See what Peachtree has to say about this picture book on its Web site.
If you’d like to read this book, visit your local library or bookstore. If you’ve already read it, tell us what you think!
Check back often for more kid book reviews.
4 Responses to “ KID REVIEW: Join Jaiden in discussing A Tree for Emmy ”
Trackbacks & Pingbacks:
-
[...] If you’re interested in seeing more cool books about trees, see Paul’s review of The Busy Tree and Jaiden’s review of A Tree for Emmy. [...]

Well, this makes me want to read Emmy’s Tree, that’s for sure! Thanks, Princess Reads-a-Lot!
Thank you, Jaiden. Not only are you the youngest reviewer I’ve ever had for one of my books, you are definitely one of the best. Thank YOU, Princess Reads-a-Lot (and her friend, Pat). I used to live in Wisconsin, and as far as I know, mimosas don’t grow that far north. I live in Georgia (down South) and I have lots of mimosas growing “stubborn and strong and a little bit wild” in my back yard. When they bloom again next summer, I will send you a picture of them.
thanks for a nice review, did you know Emmy just won a prize? (Giverny prize for 2011)
I’m tickled pink!